SOUTH BEND, Ind. – For 38 years, Miami has insisted the same thing: Cleveland Gary didn’t fumble in a still-debated loss at Notre Dame.
Now, that infamous play has some company in the annals of college football controversy. The rivalry between the Miami Hurricanes and the Notre Dame Fighting Irish has been marked by memorable moments and contentious calls, and the latest game added a new chapter.
During a recent game that ended in a 31-24 loss for Miami, the Hurricanes found themselves once again on the wrong side of a crucial officiating decision. Late in the fourth quarter, Elija Lofton appeared to catch what could have been a game-tying touchdown pass. However, the referees ruled that Lofton did not complete the catch, igniting a debate that echoes the past.
“They negated Elija Lofton’s touchdown with two hands on the ball and two feet inbounds,” Miami coach Mario Cristobal expressed his frustration following the game. “Like we told our team before we left Miami, do not leave it in the hands of the officials. … Congratulations to Notre Dame for winning the game, but very disappointed in the way that was called with the game on the line and clear possession of a football inbounds.”
Had Lofton’s catch been ruled valid, Miami would have been in a position to attempt an extra point to tie the game, a scenario reminiscent of their 1988 matchup with Notre Dame. In that game, Miami also lost 31-30, a game that is forever etched in the minds of Hurricanes fans due to the controversial call involving Cleveland Gary’s fumble.
Both games featured Miami entering as the No. 1 ranked team in the country, while Notre Dame was ranked No. 4, creating a parallel that heightens the stakes of these encounters.
“I thought it was a touchdown,” Miami quarterback Darian Mensah stated, echoing the sentiments of many fans who believed the catch should have counted.
The crux of the controversy lay in whether Lofton had full control of the ball at the time of the hit from Notre Dame’s Luke Talich. Talich noted, “I felt like he didn’t have control of it. I was glad. I was super pumped-up when they upheld it.”
Terry McAulay, a rules analyst for NBC, sided with the officials’ decision, explaining, “You see him bobble it just a little bit before the ball gets knocked out. It’s incomplete.”
The 1988 loss still resonates deeply with Miami, as it denied them a chance at the national title. Former Miami star Randal Hill lamented, “Robbed. We were robbed,” referring to the Gary fumble that still stings in Miami’s history.
While this latest loss does not eliminate Miami from College Football Playoff contention, it certainly leaves fans debating the implications of the Lofton call. The Hurricanes demonstrated resilience, rallying from a 24-3 deficit, which surprised many given the absence of star receiver Malachi Toney due to injury.
Toney was a standout player, contributing significantly to Miami’s offense prior to his injury, and his absence was felt keenly. Nevertheless, Cooper Barkate and Lofton stepped up, showcasing the depth of the team despite the heartbreaking loss.
“I was celebrating,” Mensah recalled. “I thought it was a touchdown,” illustrating the emotional rollercoaster experienced by players and fans alike during the game.
As the debate over Lofton’s catch continues, it serves as a reminder of the passionate rivalry between Miami and Notre Dame, a rivalry steeped in history, controversy, and unforgettable moments.
___
Sign up for Top 25 poll alerts here. Visit the Top 25 here and see AP’s full college football coverage here.
