NEW YORK – A federal appeals court is currently considering whether it can intervene in a significant legal case involving former President Donald Trump. This case stems from a hush money payment that he made, and it has garnered a lot of attention. Recently, a New York State appellate court heard arguments regarding Trump’s attempt to overturn a historical conviction.
The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals recently held a session where a three-judge panel spent over an hour questioning Trump’s lawyer, Robert Giuffra Jr., and a state prosecutor. They discussed Trump’s efforts to move the case from state court to federal court, where he hopes to have it dismissed based on presidential immunity. However, no immediate decision was reached.
This hearing marks the second time in just 11 days that both sides have appeared in court as Trump pursues a dual legal strategy to overturn his conviction. In May 2024, Trump was found guilty on 34 felony counts related to falsifying business records to cover up a $130,000 payment made to adult film performer Stormy Daniels.
Alongside his federal court battle, Trump is also appealing through New York’s state court system. This includes arguments presented in the mid-level Appellate Division on November 5, with a ruling still pending.
The case has significant implications for Trump, as he is the first U.S. president to be convicted of a crime. He continues to maintain his innocence and is determined to clear his name as he campaigns for a return to the White House.
During the recent court session, Giuffra urged the judges to act quickly, even before they finalize their full decision. He argued that without federal court intervention, Trump might face years of waiting for the state appellate courts to make a ruling before he could potentially take the case to the U.S. Supreme Court.
However, the judges expressed skepticism about the feasibility of such a request. Judge John M. Walker Jr. and Chief Judge Raymond J. Lohier Jr. raised concerns about how the transfer of the case from state to federal court would work, noting that there had already been significant arguments and filings in the state court.
Giuffra explained that if the case were to move to federal court, it would likely start with a federal district court judge adopting the state court’s verdict before proceeding to the 2nd Circuit for arguments regarding the immunity claims. Despite this, Judge Lohier pointed out that federal law does not clearly authorize such a procedural transfer.
Trump has previously attempted to shift the case to federal court multiple times. In August, a federal judge ruled against him for the third time, stating that paying hush money to an adult film star does not fall under presidential immunity. Trump first sought to move the case after his indictment in March 2023 and has continued to pursue this route after his conviction.
Giuffra contended that prosecutors improperly used evidence of Trump’s official actions, which had been deemed inadmissible by the Supreme Court in a ruling regarding presidential immunity. He argued that the hush money payment should be evaluated as a federal issue rather than a state matter.
In contrast, Steven Wu, chief of the appeals division at the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office, urged the court to maintain the case in state court. He pointed out that even if Trump were to prevail, the state appeals court would still have the authority to make a ruling.
This legal battle is far from over, and its outcome could have lasting implications for Trump’s political future and the legal landscape surrounding presidential immunity.

