BEXAR COUNTY, Texas – A nearly 50-year-old cold case involving a murder in Universal City that was thought to have been resolved has taken a surprising turn. On Monday, the Bexar County District Attorney’s Office announced that they were dismissing the case against Kelly Lee Brower, 68, due to insufficient evidence.
Brower was arrested in Arizona on August 19 and was facing a $1 million bond. Texas Rangers believed he was linked to the murder of Yolanda Herrera, whose tragic death in 1981 left a lasting mark on the community. However, after a thorough review, the DA’s office concluded that they did not have enough evidence to proceed with a capital murder charge.
The district attorney’s office expressed their condolences to Yolanda’s family, explaining, “While we recognize this outcome is disappointing to Ms. Herrera’s family and sympathize with their grief, we also informed them that if new evidence emerges, the case can be reopened.” This statement highlights the ongoing hope for justice, as the family grapples with the disappointment of the case being dismissed.
Background of the Case
The investigation into Yolanda Herrera’s murder began decades ago. According to Brower’s arrest affidavit, significant evidence, including DNA from a discarded beer can and a confession made in a hospital, led Texas Rangers to revisit this cold case.
In a groundbreaking move, investigators submitted old DNA evidence to Othram Laboratories, which used advanced sequencing techniques to identify Brower as a likely suspect. They discovered that the probability of a random person sharing the DNA profile found at the crime scene was as low as 1 in 31 billion in the U.S. population.
On October 2025, police collected a Coors Light beer can from outside Brower’s home, which matched DNA found on Herrera’s fingernails taken during her autopsy in 1981. This crucial link suggested Brower was present at the scene of the crime.
During interviews with Texas Rangers, Brower initially denied knowing Herrera, but later, while in the hospital, he made statements that seemed to implicate himself. He reportedly mentioned that his “higher self” admitted to killing Herrera, and when shown a photo of her, he acknowledged having had sexual contact with her.
Brower’s connections to the area were significant as well. He lived less than a mile from where Herrera’s body was found and had a history that placed him in Universal City around the time of the murder.
Yolanda Herrera, a 23-year-old woman, was last seen on April 11, 1981, leaving a bar called Johnny’s Inn in Schertz. Her body was discovered two days later in a field, and an autopsy revealed that she had suffered multiple blunt force trauma injuries, resulting in her death.
This case highlights the complexities of solving cold cases, where new technology can shed light on long-standing mysteries. The Bexar County District Attorney’s Office has emphasized their commitment to justice, leaving the door open for the investigation to be revisited should new evidence come to light.

