Subscribe to The Y’all — a weekly dispatch about the people, places and policies defining Texas, produced by Texas Tribune journalists living in communities across the state.
In Odessa, Jon Rosenthal, a state lawmaker and oil field engineer, has set his sights on the Texas Railroad Commission, a pivotal regulatory body for the state’s oil and gas industry. His campaign initially aimed to elucidate the agency’s nuances while presenting himself as the ideal choice for voters.
However, the political landscape shifted dramatically when his opponent, Bo French, a conservative figure known for his controversial remarks, escalated the campaign discourse through incendiary social media posts.
French, who has previously stirred controversy with his provocative and often racially charged comments, has shifted the focus of the campaign to topics like foreign land ownership, immigration, and LGBTQ+ policies. These issues, while resonating with certain voter segments, are largely outside the commission’s purview.
In September, French’s remarks about the racial dynamics at the University of Texas-Austin sparked national attention, inadvertently providing Rosenthal with a critical opportunity to challenge the Republican stronghold on the commission. If successful, Rosenthal would become the first Democrat to hold a seat on the commission since the 1990s.
Rosenthal’s background as an oil field engineer informs his policy proposals, which include targeting chronic polluters, enhancing oversight on natural gas facilities, and establishing a fee for companies storing oil and gas wastewater underground to fund abandoned well closures.
Despite an influx of donations following the viral incident, Rosenthal’s campaign struggles to match the financial backing typically enjoyed by Democratic candidates in Texas. Meanwhile, French remains undeterred, pledging to reduce energy prices, cut regulations, and oppose diversity and inclusion initiatives.
The upcoming election on November 3 holds significant implications, as the winner will join a commission overseeing a substantial budget and critical decisions impacting the state’s oil and gas sector. Commissioners are tasked with approving drilling permits, enforcing penalties for violations, and managing wastewater disposal programs.
French, with deep ties to the oil industry through his family’s company, French Oil, has a history of controversial statements. His leadership of the Tarrant County Republican Party was marred by remarks that drew condemnation even from within his party, including a notable instance where he faced backlash for a poll questioning the perceived threats posed by different religious groups to the U.S.
Despite these controversies, French has adapted his campaign message to emphasize deregulation and promoting oil production, arguing that increased output would benefit Texas’s refining capabilities.
Experts, however, express skepticism about the viability of this approach, suggesting that flooding the market with oil could depress prices and harm the industry in the long run. French’s stance aligns with a broader Republican narrative favoring less regulation on fossil fuel production.
Rosenthal, on the other hand, aims to position himself as a responsible alternative, focusing on environmental regulations and safety measures for natural gas facilities, particularly in light of extreme weather events.
Having previously unseated a long-standing Republican incumbent, Rosenthal is no stranger to overcoming political challenges. However, he faces the daunting task of raising awareness and funds in a landscape dominated by his opponent’s controversial rhetoric.
With the election approaching, recent polls indicate a tight race, with Rosenthal holding a slight edge over French, which could signal a shift in voter sentiment amidst growing dissatisfaction with the Republican establishment.
As the candidates prepare for their upcoming debate in Dallas, the stakes are high for both Rosenthal and French. The outcome of this election could reshape the future of the Texas Railroad Commission and its impact on the state’s oil and gas industry.
